In Long Eddy, New York, the Rock Valley Artist Compound offers a truly unique setting, where a converted church and Grange Hall have been artfully transformed into an extraordinary apartment and artist studio. Each space possesses its own remarkable qualities; this is an opportunity to own both.


Two bedroom, one bathroom converted church | 1,600 square foot apartment on .44 acres | Preserved arched doors | High ceilings and refinished flooring | Original, vertical stained glass windows | Library nook | 3-season w/a Reznor vented heater | Electric stand-alone water heater | Belfry with views of the valley | Flower garden and babbling brook | One bedroom, one bathroom converted Grange hall | 1,848 square foot studio home on .5 acres | Full kitchen | Fenced vegetable garden | Asking $650,000

Listed by Erik Freeland at Country House Realty. View the original listing here. Open House: Sunday, July 9, 1-3 pm at 9052 and 9030 County Hwy 28, Long Eddy, NY 12760. For showings or inquiries, email erik@countryhouserealty.com or call (646) 942-7099.


The Church (C.1893):

Photographs by Erik Freeland

The church has transformed into a two bedroom, one bathroom home while still maintaining its exquisite original details of the 1890s. The soaring ceilings, preserved arched doors, and huge vertical windows with original stained glass create an awe-inspiring space. The expansive accordion doors separate the kitchen from living/dining area. The property boasts beautiful, architectural angles and refinished beech floors that span every corner.

The living area exudes an enormous sense of volume yet still has an intimate and welcoming feel. A large dining table serves as a wonderful focal point for entertaining. The bathroom is adjacent to a cozy library nook. The bright kitchen features a generously sized butcher-block island.

Up the stairs is the main bedroom featuring the original stained glass window. This room easily accommodates a king-size bed and two built-in closets. Continuing up the small stairs is an open space fit for an office. The smaller bedroom is also off the main room. Wainscotting runs throughout and the ceiling detail is skillfully accentuated.

Ascending even higher up the stairs is access to the belfry, offering breathtaking vistas of the valley. Enjoy a serene morning coffee or savor an evening cocktail. Outside the home is a flower garden, bluestone patio, and babbling brook.

The building has been converted to three-season living but could be insulated and heated for all year.

The Grange Hall  (C.1886):

Grange halls were multi-use community spaces. Locals would gather for ceremonies, entertainment of live music and dancing, and for town meetings or voting. This instance has undergone a thorough renovation and modernization, while still preserving its attractive and humble aesthetic.

The lower floor has a fully functional one-bedroom, one-bath apartment. There is a full modern kitchen that seamlessly opens to a dining and living area. The original wood walls were painted and the original floors rejuvenated.

As a painter, the owner required a spacious area to accommodate large canvases. The upper floor transformed into the ideal studio. There is abundant light, lofty ceilings, a convenient slop sink, and room for creativity to thrive.

The Grange includes new windows and complete insulation, ensuring a comfortable living environment throughout the year. It is equipped with propane water baseboard heating. It also features a fenced vegetable garden at the back and has also served as an intermittent short-term rental, offering a flexible accommodation option for temporary stays.

Situated in lower Delaware County, just 20 minutes away from Callicoon, NY, and a little over 2 hours from the GWB, the Rock Valley Artist Compound provides a serene and inspiring setting for those seeking a unique and creative lifestyle.


For transparency, Escape Brooklyn is a real estate advertising service and may have been paid for this ad. We carefully curate potential paid advertisers; all features are hand-picked and thoughtfully considered.