Six-unit Victorian multifamily property | 4,091 square feet home on 0.11 acres | Built in 1870 | Mix of one studio, four one-bedroom units (two with bonus rooms), and one two-bedroom | Wraparound porch and ornate shingle façade | Historic millwork | Hudson River views from multiple units | Located in the East End Historic District | Includes separately deeded vacant lot preserving unobstructed Hudson River views | Eligible for 444A Tax Exemption and SHPO Tax Credit programs | Recent improvements and professional management
Built in 1870 and located within the East End Historic District, this six-unit Victorian home pairs timeless architecture with modern performance. Once derelict, it has been reimagined by its current owner as both a neighborhood landmark and a fully stabilized income property, preserving historic character while embracing contemporary design and comfort.
Behind its shingled façade and wraparound porch are six distinct apartments, each thoughtfully restored. Period millwork, leaded-glass windows, arched doorways, and tiled fireplaces recall the home’s 19th-century craftsmanship, while modern kitchens, updated baths, and custom finishes bring the building firmly into the present. Notable highlights include mirrored octagonal rooms with oversized windows, marble countertops and eat-in islands, French doors between living and sleeping areas, and a top-floor unit with a deep soaking tub and balcony with sprawling Hudson River views.
Currently configured as five long-term rentals and one high-performing short-term unit, the property has a proven history of strong income and operational flexibility. A separately deeded, non-buildable lot across the street is included in the sale, preserving panoramic river views for the long term. With its combination of architectural integrity, financial strength, and prime positioning on one of Newburgh’s most picturesque bluff streets, this historic home presents the opportunity to own one of the city’s most distinctive riverfront properties.
Asking $1,625,000. Listed by Sarah Hooff at ReAttached Real Estate. For showings or inquiries, contact Sarah at sarah@reattached.team or text/call 845-420-8965.
Open house: Friday, October 17 from 1 – 3 pm at 2 Courtney Avenue, Newburgh, NY 12550. RSVP requested but not required.
The Neighborhood: In + Around Newburgh, NY
The home’s location in the East End Historic District puts much of Newburgh’s creative energy within reach. Start the day with coffee at Baristas on Broadway, then explore the neighborhood’s mix of shops, restaurants, and Victorian streetscapes. For casual bites, Hudson Taco has become a local favorite for street tacos and margaritas. For vintage shopping, the Newburgh Vintage Emporium is a short drive away and is packed with well-curated furniture, decor, and fashion from every era. End the day with dinner at Ms. Fairfax, where elevated American comfort food meets inventive fusion in a lively, inviting setting.
Across the bridge, Beacon offers a full day of art, shopping, and dining. Begin with breakfast at Beacon Bread Company before visiting Dia Beacon, a contemporary art museum set in a riverside factory. From there, explore Blackbird Attic for consignment fashion, Vintage:Beacon for curated vintage finds, and Witch Hazel for natural skincare and home goods. Evenings in Beacon can be spent at The Roundhouse or Quinn’s for dinner and cocktails, with a visit to Wonderbar for a nightcap.
Our Favorite Details: Historic Architecture, Accents and Neighborhood
Built in 1870, this home stands as a classic example of Victorian architecture within Newburgh’s East End Historic District. Its defining features – steeply pitched roofs, asymmetrical form, and elaborate trimwork – reflect the craftsmanship of the era. A grand wraparound porch frames the ornate exterior, where decorative shingle motifs and detailed woodwork give the property its distinctive, castle-like character. Inside, original millwork and wainscoting remain beautifully preserved, while octagonal and circular tower-style rooms add a sculptural rhythm to the interior layout.
This historic apartment building sits on Bay View Terrace in a bluffside neighborhood shaped by the city’s 19th-century shipping and industrial past. Once a hub for river trade and regional commerce, the area is defined by steeply pitched roofs, ornate Victorian detailing, and picturesque homes overlooking the Hudson. Walking the streets today, the historic character feels alive – from grand wraparound porches to Carpenter Gothic flourishes – while the bluff above the river gives a quiet, elevated perspective on the city below.