5 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms renovated 1830s church | Fully reimagined in 2023 by ICDT Studio | 6,242 square foot home on 37.006 acres | Open layout living space | Sculptural gas fireplace | Chef’s kitchen with oversized island and AGA range | Cupola library with chandelier | 625-bottle wine room | Private primary wing with spa-like bathroom | Sweeping views of the Catskill Mountains | Raised deck | Pea gravel patio with fire pit | On-site trails, stream, and seasonal waterfall | Furniture available for purchase

Tucked into the northern Catskills, Potter Mountain House unfolds with a sense of arrival and quiet intention. Surrounded by 37 acres of wooded trails, meadows, and mountain views, the residence bridges past and present with uncommon clarity. What began as a nineteenth-century church has been reimagined as a refined country retreat — equal parts grounded and grand in its design.

Inside, the home’s thoughtful transformation comes into full view. The entryway introduces a palette of natural materials and clean lines, with wide-plank white oak floors and refined finishes that echo throughout. Just beyond, the chef’s kitchen unfolds in a blend of form and function, anchored by a sleek stone island and outfitted with an induction range, Fisher & Paykel appliances, Waterworks fixtures, and a walk-in pantry clad in custom tile and reclaimed beams. From here, the space flows into an open-concept living room, where the home’s original 1837 timber frame rises to dramatic heights. Soaring ceilings and hand-hewn beams draw the eye upward, while a full wall of windows frames sweeping Catskills views. A round, sculptural fireplace anchors the transition to the formal dining area, which opens to a 625-bottle wine room enclosed by arched, custom iron doors.

Up the symmetrical double stair, the original church cupola has been reimagined as a library loft, now crowned by an 18-foot glass chandelier and wrapped in floor-to-ceiling built-ins. A separate staircase leads to the private primary suite, occupying its own wing with vaulted ceilings, a spacious walk-in closet, and a spa-like bath featuring dual vanities, a wet room shower with dual showerheads, and a deep soaking tub. Additional bedrooms are located on the lower level, which also features a secondary living area with a wet bar, two guest bedrooms, a built-in bunk room, and a generous laundry suite with double washers and dryers.

Set on 37 acres of sweeping land, the outdoor spaces offer layered moments for gathering and quiet escape — from the cedar deck patio positioned to overlook wildflower meadows, wooded trails, and a stream-fed ravine with seasonal waterfalls. A heated two-car garage and all-purpose mudroom add year-round ease, while a comprehensive landscape plan includes designs for a future pool. Though tucked into nature, the property is just 20 minutes from Windham Mountain Club and under an hour to the thriving upstate town of Hudson. Rooted in the landscape yet minutes from culture and skiing, it’s a refined home base for year-round Catskills living.

Asking $3,895,000. Listed by Anthony D’Argenzio and Jessica Brasseur at the This Old Hudson Team at Houlihan Lawrence. For showings or inquiries, email Anthony at hello@thisoldhudson.com or call/text (518) 821-0826.

The Neighborhood: In & Around Gilboa, New York

Tucked into the northern Catskills, Potter Mountain House sits just outside of Windham — an all-season town with deep ski roots and a growing off-season appeal. At its heart, Windham’s walkable Main Street blends small-town charm with a growing roster of thoughtful dining spots. For morning provisions, Paracasa in nearby Hensonville offers well-curated coffee, takeaway breakfast, and pantry staples in a bright, unfussy space. Come evening, The Henson’s Matilda serves seasonal, locally driven fare in a modern dining room that balances polish with ease. Just down the road, Babblers at Wylder Windham offers elevated American classics and mountain views in a design-forward, lodge-style setting.

Beyond the village, Windham Mountain Club remains the region’s main draw — with 285 skiable acres in winter, and golf, hiking, and lift-served mountain biking in the warmer months. For panoramic ridgetop views, the Escarpment Trail delivers scenic payoff that spans over 22 miles, while the Blackhead Mountain Loop offers a shorter, equally rewarding hike.

Less than an hour east, Hudson makes for an easy day trip — known for its historic architecture, gallery-lined streets, and elevated retail mix. Browse artfully curated homewares at Finch, design-forward fashion at Kasuri, or mid-century treasures at Magic Hill Mercantile. Between stops, grab coffee at Hudson Roastery, or plan to grab a happy hour cocktail at The Maker‘s lounge before heading back into the mountains.

Our Favorite Details at Potter Mountain House

Originally built in 1837 as the Manorkill Methodist Church, the structure was meticulously dismantled in the 1990s and relocated to its current northern Catskills site. Each timber beam was carefully preserved, though the building remained partially converted and unfinished for more than two decades — until ICDT Studio’s comprehensive transformation in 2023.

With a deep respect for the original form, the renovation juxtaposes clean, contemporary materials against the historic framework, achieving a rare balance of architectural clarity and quiet restraint. The soaring cupola library, sculptural gathering spaces, and expansive mountain-facing windows culminate in a striking reinterpretation of rural heritage, where history meets refined modernity.